Legalization vs. Decriminalization of Prostitution: What’s the Difference?

People often use legalization and decriminalization interchangeably when talking about prostitution. They aren’t the same thing. The distinction is especially interesting in the United States, where Nevada permits prostitution through a regulated brothel system, Maine has removed the crime of selling sex while continuing to criminalize buying it, and Rhode Island once allowed indoor prostitution because of an unintended gap in its criminal law. Those three states ended up with very different legal situations.

There is no single definition of legalization or decriminalization that every government or policy organization uses in exactly the same way. As a general rule:

  • Legalization permits an activity under a legal framework that can include licenses, regulations and restrictions.
  • Decriminalization removes criminal penalties from conduct that was previously prohibited, without necessarily creating a specially licensed industry.

Marijuana offers a familiar example. A state can decriminalize possession by removing or reducing state criminal penalties without creating a legal marijuana market. Legalization under state law can go further by allowing regulated cultivation and retail sales.

What Does It Mean to Legalize Prostitution?

Legalization does not mean that an activity suddenly becomes legal everywhere, for everyone and under every circumstance. It can mean that the government has established specific conditions under which an otherwise prohibited activity becomes lawful.

Nevada provides the clearest American example. State law prohibits both the seller and the customer from engaging in prostitution outside a licensed house of prostitution. Local governments in eligible counties decide whether brothels will be licensed and regulated in their jurisdictions, while state law prevents counties with populations of 700,000 or more from licensing them.

This is why the familiar statement that “prostitution is legal in Nevada” is technically true but incomplete. Legal prostitution exists within the state’s licensed brothel system. Two people cannot legally arrange an independent prostitution transaction simply because they happen to be somewhere in Nevada.

Nevada gambling provides an easy comparison. Gambling is legal in Nevada, but you can’t open a casino in your garage and start taking bets. Nevada requires gaming operators to obtain the appropriate licenses, and operating gambling games without them is prohibited.

Casinos and brothels obviously operate under different laws and regulatory systems, but the basic principle is similar. Nevada has created a legal channel for an activity that remains illegal outside that channel. This is why Nevada is better described as a legalization and regulation model than a decriminalization model.

What Does It Mean to Decriminalize Prostitution?

Decriminalization focuses on the criminal penalties themselves. Under full decriminalization of consensual adult prostitution, neither the adult selling sex nor the adult purchasing it faces a prostitution charge simply because money was exchanged for consensual sexual activity.

That does not make every activity surrounding prostitution legal. Laws involving trafficking, coercion and commercial sex involving minors can remain in force. Businesses can still be subject to zoning, employment, health and safety requirements and other regulations.

New Zealand provides a useful international example. Its Prostitution Reform Act of 2003 explicitly states that its purpose is to decriminalize prostitution while creating a regulatory framework. The law includes health and safety requirements, local controls involving brothel locations, operator certification and prohibitions involving people under 18. Decriminalization, in other words, is not the same thing as deregulation.

Is Prostitution Decriminalized in Maine?

In 2023, Maine repealed Section 853-A of its criminal code, the offense called “Engaging in prostitution.” The current statute lists that section as repealed. But Maine did not remove criminal penalties from everyone involved in a prostitution transaction. Section 853-B still makes it a crime to engage another person for prostitution, and Maine’s sex-trafficking statute continues to criminalize knowingly promoting prostitution, subject to defenses contained in the law.

The result can be described as partial decriminalization. It also follows the basic seller-buyer distinction associated with the Nordic model, sometimes called the Swedish model. Sweden pioneered this approach in 1999 by criminalizing the purchase of sexual services while not criminalizing the sale itself, and other countries later adopted variations of the idea.

This is why saying simply that “Maine decriminalized prostitution” needs some explanation. A person selling sex no longer faces Maine’s former prostitution offense for doing so. A person buying sex can still face a criminal charge. Maine has partially decriminalized prostitution, but it has not created anything comparable to Nevada’s licensed brothel industry.

The terminology can also change depending on how someone views the law. The same system can be described as partial decriminalization because the seller is no longer prosecuted for prostitution, or partial criminalization because the buyer remains subject to criminal penalties. The law itself is clearer than the label: Maine treats the seller and buyer differently.

Rhode Island’s Accidental Decriminalization

Rhode Island may be the strangest American example because lawmakers did not originally set out to create either a Nevada-style legalization system or a modern decriminalization model.

The story goes back to 1980, when Rhode Island rewrote its prostitution law and removed language covering the act of prostitution itself while retaining prohibitions aimed at activities such as street solicitation. The consequences of that change were not immediately understood. In 1998, the Rhode Island Supreme Court ruled in State v. DeMagistris that the state’s solicitation law targeted public solicitation and did not apply to the private conduct involved in that case.

Researchers Scott Cunningham and Manisha Shah date the effective decriminalization of indoor prostitution to a 2003 District Court ruling. Their research found that the statutory gap had existed since 1980, but police, legal scholars and the public apparently did not treat indoor prostitution as decriminalized during most of the intervening years. After the 2003 ruling, the situation became much clearer.

From late 2003 until November 2009, indoor prostitution was effectively decriminalized in Rhode Island while street prostitution remained prohibited. There were no licensed brothels or anything resembling Nevada’s regulatory system. Rhode Island recriminalized prostitution in 2009, and current state law again makes prostitution a misdemeanor.

For several years, then, someone could accurately say that indoor prostitution was legal in Rhode Island and prostitution was legal in parts of Nevada. Those statements described two completely different situations. Nevada had intentionally created a system of licensed brothels. Rhode Island had an unintended gap in its criminal law that left indoor prostitution outside the prohibition.

The word legal by itself doesn’t tell you how an activity became legal or what rules surround it.

So What’s the Difference?

At the most basic level, legalization usually defines the conditions under which an activity is permitted. Decriminalization removes criminal penalties from some or all of that activity. Neither term, by itself, tells you everything you need to know about the law.

So whenever someone says prostitution has been “legalized” or “decriminalized,” there are three useful questions to ask: Legal for whom? Legal where? And under what rules? The answers usually tell you much more than the label.

ID 44457904 © Udra11 | Dreamstime.com

Comments

One response to “Legalization vs. Decriminalization of Prostitution: What’s the Difference?”

  1. […] circumstances, but the systems surrounding it are very different. Even familiar labels such as legalization and decriminalization only tell part of the story. In Nevada, the licensed brothel is central to whether the prostitution […]

Leave a Reply